Doctors are calling for a complete ban on the marketing and advertising of alcohol to reduce harmful effects of drinking on health.
In a controversial new
report, the BMA also supports minimum prices and says the industry should pay an extra tax to fund health campaigns.
The report says relying on the industry to promote sensible drinking is like "putting the fox in charge of the chicken coop".
The BBC's health correspondent, Branwen Jeffreys
reports.
TRANSCRIPT
REPORTER: Celebrating the Football League Cup, better known by the name of its sponsor Carling. Alcohol brand names back some of the biggest sporting and music events. And this is why doctors want to see the link broken—a generation who’ve grown up with binge drinking and cheap alcohol.
PROFESSOR GERARD HASTINGS, BMA REPORT AUTHOR: We’ve put our children into this environment where alcohol is promoted everywhere. We’ve reduced the price to ridiculous levels. We’ve got a range of products that include toffee vodka and all sorts of alcopops that obviously appeal to juvenile palates, and we’re surprised when they consume them and we punish them for the consuming of those products.
REPORTER: Billboards are the high-profile side of alcohol marketing. Each year the industry spends £194m on advertising on TV, radio and hoardings. But the total spend is around £800m. That includes sponsorships and promotions in bars and on the Internet. The alcohol industry’s the second largest sponsor of sports in the UK. Sponsorship agencies say withdrawing that would be devastating.
NIGEL CURRIE, EUROPEAN SPONSORSHIP ASSOCIATION: The alcohol companies provide huge funding for sport at all levels right across the board, and without it a lot of sports will really struggle to survive.
REPORTER: This industry ad is part of their effort to promote sensible drinking. Doctors want a more hard-hitting approach, paid for by a tax on industry. Alcohol producers and retailers say that’s unfair, and they argue their advertising doesn’t target young people.
MICHAEL THOMPSON, THE PORTMAN GROUP: There is a wealth of evidence that alcohol advertising and marketing causes people to choose different drinks. It influences their brand choice. It is not causing underage or harmful drinking.
REPORTER: You won’t see these any more. The advertising of tobacco is banned on health grounds, and so is the use of tobacco brands in sponsorship. Similar arguments about brand loyalty and the impact on sport were heard then. Health campaigners say alcohol is no different. Young drinkers in Newcastle today were divided on the impact of a ban.
YOUNG DRINKER 1: In the way of terms of drinking, I don’t think it would stop you drinking any less.
YOUNG DRINKER 2: You get the leaflets and things that say 2-for-1 and it makes you want to go and get two for one.
YOUNG DRINKER 3: I think advertising works subconsciously anyway, so, I mean, it probably would affect the way I drank, yeah.
REPORTER: Doctors want radical changes but they’re up against a large industry that feels unfairly targeted.
FURTHER READING
• Doctors want booze marketing ban (BBC News)
• The power of alcohol marketing (BBC News)
• Carlsberg and FA agree new deal (BBC News)
LESSON IDEA
Organize a debate with the motion "This house supports a complete ban on the advertising and marketing of alcohol."